Do Amazon sellers need an accountant?

When a generalist stops being enough, and what an ecommerce specialist actually does differently.

6 min read

Nothing obliges a sole trader to use an accountant. Plenty of Amazon sellers file their own Self Assessment for years and are perfectly right to. The question is not whether you are allowed to do it yourself - it is at what point the things you do not know start costing more than the fee.

What makes Amazon different

A high-street accountant who looks after builders and consultants is looking at a business with a handful of invoices a month. An Amazon business generates thousands of transactions, and almost none of them arrive as an invoice. What you get instead is a settlement: a fortnightly net payout that has already had referral fees, FBA fees, advertising, storage, refunds and reimbursements deducted from it before the money reaches your bank.

That single number is the root of most bad Amazon bookkeeping. Recording a £14,000 payout as £14,000 of sales understates your turnover, hides every fee you paid, and produces accounts that are wrong in both directions at once. The real figure might be £19,000 of sales less £5,000 of costs - and it is the £19,000 that counts towards your VAT registration threshold, not the £14,000 you actually received.

Then there is stock. Inventory you have bought but not yet sold is an asset, not an expense. Sellers who deduct every purchase in the month they paid for it report a loss in a good year and a windfall in a bad one, and can end up paying tax on profit they never made. Getting cost of goods sold matched to the period the goods actually sold in is the single most valuable thing an ecommerce accountant does.

The point where doing it yourself stops paying

There is rarely a dramatic moment. It is usually one of five things. You approach the VAT registration threshold and realise you are not certain what counts towards it. You start importing and discover that import VAT, duty and postponed VAT accounting are their own subject. You incorporate, and a limited company brings statutory accounts, a corporation tax return, a confirmation statement and payroll with it. You start selling into the EU or the US and acquire foreign VAT or sales tax questions. Or you simply reach the point where a day spent on spreadsheets costs more in lost sourcing than the annual fee.

The honest test is whether you can answer a straightforward question about your own numbers. What was your gross margin last quarter after Amazon's fees but before advertising? Which products lost money once storage was allocated? If you cannot get to those answers, you do not have a bookkeeping problem so much as a decision-making one - and that is expensive in ways that never show up on an invoice.

Generalist or ecommerce specialist?

A competent generalist can file a perfectly correct return for an Amazon business. What they typically cannot do is tell you anything useful about it, because they have not seen enough of them to know what normal looks like. They may also be unfamiliar with the specifics: how marketplace facilitator VAT works, why your Amazon fee invoices changed in 2024, what postponed VAT accounting does to your cash flow, or how to reconcile a settlement to the penny.

A specialist is generally worth the premium once you are VAT registered, importing, or selling across more than one marketplace. Below that, a good generalist who is willing to learn your settlement reports is often the better value. What you are really buying at the specialist end is pattern recognition - someone who has seen fifty businesses like yours and knows which of your numbers is the odd one.

Ask what software they work in, whether they have other Amazon clients, and how they handle the settlement-to-ledger step. If the answer to the last one is that they will post the net payout as sales, keep looking.

What to have ready before you speak to anyone

You will get a more useful conversation - and a more accurate quote - if you turn up with your last twelve months of settlement reports, a rough monthly sales figure, the marketplaces you sell on, whether you import, whether you are VAT registered, and whether you trade as a sole trader or a limited company.

It is also worth being straight about the state of your records. Accountants price partly on how much cleaning up they expect to do, and a firm that discovers three years of unreconciled stock after quoting will either re-quote or do a worse job. Nobody is impressed by tidy books at the first meeting; they are impressed by an accurate description of untidy ones.

Compare UK accountants

Browse the full directory by city, services and published pricing.

Browse the directory